Arsenal vs. Everton prediction, odds, time: 2024 English Premier League picks, best bets for May 19

Published on May 18, 2024

With the season coming to a close, Arsenal still have a slim shot at English Premier League glory. The Gunners (27-5-5) need to not only defeat Everton in Sunday's match, but will need West Ham to either pull off a stunning victory or a draw when they face table-leading Manchester City. Arsenal sit second on the table with 86 points, two shy of the Citizens, but could own the tiebreaker if they find themselves even in points after Sunday's matches. The Toffees (13-9-15), 15th on the table, have 40 points after having eight points docked in penalties this season, and would love nothing better than to play the role of spoiler.

Kickoff is set for 11 a.m. ET at Emirates Stadium in London, England. Arsenal are listed as the -700 favorites (risk $700 to win $100) in its latest Arsenal vs. Everton odds, with Everton the +1600 underdogs. A draw is priced at +700 and the over/under for total goals scored is 3.5. Before locking in any Everton vs. Arsenal picks, you need to see what proven SportsLine soccer insider Jon "Buckets" Eimer has to say.

Eimer is a high-volume bettor who has vast knowledge of leagues and players across the globe. Since joining SportsLine, he has covered the English Premier League, Serie A, the FA Cup and much more. In 2023, he was red-hot, going 248-234-12 for a profit of $2,593 for $100 bettors. That included an 86-59-5 record in the Premier League for a $3,463 profit. Anyone who follows him is way up.

Now, Eimer has broken down Arsenal vs. Everton from every angle and revealed his picks and English Premier League predictions. You can head to SportsLine now to see Eimer's picks. Here are the betting lines and trends for Everton vs. Arsenal:

  • Arsenal vs. Everton money line: Arsenal -700, Draw +700, Everton +1600
  • Arsenal vs. Everton over/under: 3.5 goals
  • Arsenal vs. Everton spread: Arsenal -2.5 (+115)
  • Arsenal: The Gunners have a league-best goal differential of plus-61 in Premier League action this season
  • Everton: The Toffees have scored 39 goals in league play in 2023-2024, second-worst among the 20 teams
  • Arsenal vs. Everton picks: See picks here
Why you should back Arsenal

Forward Bukayo Saka helps power the Gunners' offense with a team-high 16 goals and eight assists in 35 appearances, all starts. He has scored two goals and added one assist over the past four matches, taking 16 shots with seven being on target. In a 3-0 win over AFC Bournemouth on May 4, he scored a goal on seven shots, including three on net. He also had a goal on three shots, including two on target in a 3-2 win at Tottenham Hotspur on April 28. For the season, he has taken 109 shots with 37 on net.

Another solid weapon on offense has been midfielder Kai Havertz. The 24-year-old German has three goals and two assists over the past four matches. In a 5-0 win over Chelsea, he scored a pair of goals on four shots, all on target. He had a goal and an assist in the win at Tottenham. In 36 appearances, including 29 starts, Havertz has scored 12 goals and added seven assists on 56 shots, including 23 on target. See which team to pick here. 

Why you should back Everton

Midfielder Abdoulaye Doucoure is among the Toffees' leading scorers. In 31 matches, all starts, he has scored seven goals and added two assists on 44 shots, including 20 on net. In Saturday's win over Sheffield United, he registered the lone goal after taking four shots, including three on target. He had an assist in a 2-0 win over Nottingham Forest on April 21.

Another option on offense is forward Dominic Calvert-Lewin. The 27-year-old has scored seven goals and added two assists in 31 appearances, including 25 starts. He has been red hot of late, scoring three goals and adding an assist over the past five matches. In the May 11 win over Sheffield, he posted an assist. He had goals in a 1-1 draw with Luton Town and in wins over Liverpool (2-0) and Burnley (1-0). See which team to pick here.

How to make Everton vs. Arsenal picks

Eimer has broken down the match from every possible angle and is leaning Over on the total. He also locked in a confident best bet that returns plus money. He's sharing his Premier League picks and analysis only at SportsLine.

So what is the best bet for Arsenal vs. Everton? Visit SportsLine now to see which wagers in Everton vs. Arsenal have all the value, all from the soccer expert who was up well over $2,500 for $100 players in 2023, and find out.

How to get in-depth soccer coverage daily

The CBS Sports Golazo Network has you covered with soccer news, highlights, analysis, and exclusive games. The 24-hour digital network provides around-the-clock soccer viewing to fans across the country, including morning shows and live matches. It launched in April and has been a smashing success thus far, expanding its offerings every week. Watch the CBS Sports Golazo Network now here.

The CBS Sports Golazo Network provides soccer fans with wall-to-wall coverage of the most popular game in the world. Check it out now on CBSSports.com, the CBS Sports app for connected TV devices, the CBS Sports mobile app, Pluto TV or Paramount+.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Receive regular soccer updates about our products, special offers and more!

We value your privacy and we’ll never send irrelevant information

Editors Top Picks